The integrity of the initiative has come into question as over 400 first-time homebuyers have been accused of defrauding the system by placing tenants in their newly acquired homes. This move blatantly defies the scheme’s stipulation that the property must be owner-occupied and not rented out as an investment.
Homeowners beneficiary under this program saved an average of $20,000, thanks to the scheme's broadened criteria, encompassing homes valued up to $1 million. Yet, the spirit of this relief fund has been undermined by a substantial number of individuals opting to rent out these properties covertly.
In many instances, these deceptive activities came to light when tenants reported their landlords for irregularities such as maintaining the utilities bills in the owners' names, thereby alerting the authorities. This crackdown has been driven by aggressive investigative efforts from Revenue NSW, particularly their compliance team.
NSW’s Minister for Finance, Courtney Houssos, voiced the government's unwavering commitment to ensuring the scheme reaches its legitimate beneficiaries while maintaining fairness across the board. Houssos stated, "The Minns Labor Government is steadfast in its goal to provide substantial support for first-home buyers amid the current cost-of-living crisis."
Echoing the sentiment, Chief Commissioner of State Revenue, Scott Johnston, emphasized the imperative nature of compliance. Johnston remarked, "Our compliance team plays a crucial role in preserving the integrity of first-home buyer initiatives. Their dedication ensures that the scheme remains fair and benefits those genuinely in need."
Originating from a report by News.com.au, the efforts of Revenue NSW have borne fruit. Over $9 million was recovered following exhaustive investigations intended to weed out non-compliant participants.
During the expanded scheme’s first year, an impressive 33,365 first-home buyers benefited, avoiding or reducing stamp duty expenses. Specifically, buyers of sub-$1 million properties could take advantage of either complete or partial stamp duty exemptions.
The rigorous compliance program facilitated by Revenue NSW has notably undertaken 718 investigations in 2023/24 alone, causing 422 individuals to refund some or all of their wrongly acquired benefits. As a collective, Australia's first-home buyers saved more than $683 million on stamp duty during this period.
Particularly striking are the numbers highlighted within specific locales. Approximately 5,600 participants from suburban regions such as Cumberland, Blacktown, and Parramatta accomplished a combined savings of $115 million, while in regional areas like Central Coast, Wagga Wagga, and Tweed, over 13,000 residents similarly profited.
The investigative processes are not arbitrary, leveraging a systematic data matching program to pinpoint inconsistencies. Revenue NSW’s checks integrate data from the NSW Government Rental Bonds Board, the Department of Home Affairs, and the Australian Taxation Office to ensure rigorous scrutiny and uphold the scheme’s equity.
